Competing on Speed

Emiliano S. Pagnotta, Thomas Philippon

Econometrica, 2018 Part of Firms and financial market structure

  • Project awarded with a grant from the Smith Richardson Foundation

Abstract

We analyze trading speed and fragmentation in asset markets. In our model, trading venues make technological investments and compete for investors who choose where and how much to trade. Faster venues charge higher fees and attract speed-sensitive investors. Competition among venues increases investor participation, trading volume, and allocative efficiency, but entry and fragmentation can be excessive, and speeds are generically inefficient. Regulations that protect transaction prices (e.g., Securities and Exchange Commission trade-through rule) lead to greater fragmentation. Our model sheds light on the experience of European and U.S. markets since the implementation of Markets in Financial Instruments Directive and Regulation National Markets System.

Bubble chart of electronic trading uptake, as a share of 2013 USD volume, against typical transaction speed for asset classes from U.S. high-yield corporate bonds to S&P 500 futures; bubble size shows average daily turnover.
Trading speed across asset classes. Share of 2013 US-dollar volume traded electronically, against typical transaction speed, from human to machine (one second or less); bubble size shows average daily turnover. Corporate bonds and swaps remain largely human-traded; futures and institutional equities are almost fully electronic. Source: TABB Group and various sources.

Notes

NBER Working Paper 17652

Online Appendix: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2047536

Cite

Emiliano S. Pagnotta and Thomas Philippon (2018). "Competing on Speed." Econometrica 86(3): 1067–1115.

@article{https://doi.org/10.3982/ECTA10762,
  author  = {Pagnotta, Emiliano S. and Philippon, Thomas},
  title   = {Competing on Speed},
  journal = {Econometrica},
  volume  = {86},
  number  = {3},
  pages   = {1067-1115},
  year    = {2018},
  doi     = {https://doi.org/10.3982/ECTA10762}
}

Presentations

AEA, WFA, SED, Cowles Foundation, FTG

  • 2011–2012 Cowles Foundation General Equilibrium Conference, Yale U.